Is This the End of the Greenback?

Since its emergence as the global reserve currency after the Second World War, the United States (“US”) Dollar’s role as world’s currency has not faced the level of scrutiny it currently faces. Following the demystification of the US economy by the Financial Crisis of 2007-2009, and resulting fiscal deficit, there have been calls to review the role of the US Dollar as the global reserve currency.

America enjoys several benefits from this role. Seigniorage, the income a country generates by issuing its currency, appears to be one. The profit derived from the issuance of additional currency to non US residents who hold US notes and coins is estimated to be about $10 billion annually. Also, the high demand for the Dollar ensures its protection from fluctuation. The global demand for the Dollar has in effect, insulated it from volatility. There are also socio-political benefits. America is the world’s largest economy and considered to be the bankers to the world, allowing it wield enormous political influence. As Henry Kissinger said, “he, who controls money, controls the world.”

The US also bears the burdens attached to such responsibility. The high global demand for the Dollar, and the need to maintain liquidity, makes it difficult for the US government to run a surplus budget. The exposure of the US economy to creditors such as China has significant disadvantages to America. The prophecy that the Chinese government will take a swipe at the US in order to overtake it as the world’s leading power is not improbable. The effect of China dumping the over 11 million US treasury securities it currently holds will collapse the US economy. China has in recent times, had the ability to artificially manipulate the value of the Dollar by intervening in its own currency by largely underpricing its Renminbi when compared to the Dollar, thereby leaving it undervalued.

The global economy has benefited from the US Dollar being the global reserve currency. Its use as a global medium of exchange cannot be overstated; largely reducing the cost of international transaction and greatly reducing currency risk that may arise in transacting with more than two currencies. The value of international trade that is invoiced in Dollars is much larger than the total trade conducted by the US and countries with currencies linked to the greenback. Also most countries can protect the value of their currencies by intervening with their Dollar dominated foreign reserves. Where the market forces are not favorable to a country’s currency (the supply of the currency outweighs the demand, which will lead to drop in value of the currency), the country can purchase the excess supply of its currency using its Dollar reserves. This stabilizes the value of its currency. Though this act of intervention divides economists, it is still common practice among numerous countries, notably Nigeria.

However, these benefits also come with drawbacks. One of such is that the US can take certain monetary steps without considering the global economy. The Stiglitz Report claimed that “US monetary policies were implemented with little consideration of their impact on global aggregate demand or demands for global liquidity and were thus a cause of instability in exchange rates and global activity” in reference to America’s response to the excess Dollar liquidity in the 1970s. There is the increased risk of doomsday if the Dollar fails. The “Triffin Dilemma” propounded by renowned economist Robert Triffin, asserts that where a single currency (such as the Dollar) acts as the global reserve currency, the increased need to fuel global liquidity will lead to an increase in the supply of that currency. This will result in an increased budget deficit of that country supplying the currency which will one day erode the value of that currency.

The world has put its eggs in one basket. Will the global economy survive the failure of the Dollar? Is the US really too big to fail? Using the Dollar as the global currency reserve creates a systemic risk to the world that is too large to overlook. The question on everyone’s lips is, “to be or not to be”? Has the Dollar outspent its usefulness as the global reserve currency? Is it time for the Dollar to vacate this position for another currency or group of currencies?

March 23, 2009 is a day of significant importance. On this day, Zhou Xiaochuan the Governor of Central Bank of US’ largest creditor, China, called for a replacement of the Dollar as the dominant world currency. He suggested the creation of an international reserve currency issued to a stable benchmark, disconnected from individual nations. Should China’s Renminbi replace the Dollars as the world’s global reserve currency? China has relaxed restrictions on its currency allowing foreign holders trade its currency to some extent. This has encouraged numerous trade partners like Nigeria to adopt the Renminbi as a tradeable currency. However, China’s currency regulation is far from perfect. There are allegations that China is intervening in its currency, as the rate its currency currently exchanges, does not reflect the growth in its economy. There is no guaranteed independence of the Chinese Central Bank from the political leadership of the country, a major flaw in its system. The alteration of the Renminbi for the US Dollar does not remove the systemic risk of the use of one currency as global reserve currency.

Will a dual or multiple global reserve currency system solve this problem? This system will solve the primary problem of over reliance on only one currency as the global reserve currency. However, this system also brings along its own complexities. First, it is more complex to transact in more than one currency. Secondly, where the dual currency system applies, holders automatically double the currency risk they face.

The ‘savior’ appears to have arrived or so it seems. The proposed system is an improvement on Keynesian idea of an international reserve currency issued by a supranational bank. The Stigitz Report suggests the Special Deposit Receipts (“SDR”) issued by the IMF be utilized as the global reserve currency. The report further proposes that a Global Reserve Bank should be set-up by the IMF to run this. Global currencies will be issued to the IMF in exchange for SDRs in similar quotas with the IMF quota creating a global security backed by a number of currencies. The exchange rate of the SDR will be an average of all the currencies held.

In conclusion, it is clear that though the Dollar is not dead, it is terminally ill. However, the world should not be quick to jettison the US Dollar until a well-structured alternative is available. The proposed SDR appears to be a good alternative; the intricacies have to be properly worked on and all nations be carried along in the process of establishing the new global reserve currency.



15 thoughts on “Is This the End of the Greenback?

  1. This reminds me of the song ”The Day the Dollar Dies” by Peter Tosh. Although I barely understand 1/4 of what you’ve written here, I still think this is a lovely post! More grease to your elbow, sir!

  2. Ok, never mind the misplaced ‘is’ and d need-to-be-polished writing organization skills… but definitely serves to help ‘dummies’ like me understand all the ‘Dollar talk’ I’ve heard/read in the news lately.

    Sounds like the world is at an almost inevitable edge of major change… I fear for who will be the victims.

    Very very informative read man… keep it up and don’t stop!

  3. Nice first post!

    A few years ago, the most viable contender was the euro, partly because of perceived stability and the sheer size of the eurozone economy. The current crisis has however shown its (currently near-terminal) weaknesses. Unless they can effectively create a fiscal union, it will not be a possible replacement for the dollar on the short run. The RMB has also been discussed, and apart from the problem of lack of trust in the Chinese authorities, Chinese authorities themselves are pretty wary of letting others handle their currency – it is even hard for bonds traders in Hong Kong to access Chinese bonds because of the micro-managing. And in any case, the RMB is still somewhat pegged to the dollar.

    This is the first time I’m reading about the Stiglitz report’s proposition – thanks for pointing to it. I think the proposition sounds great in theory, but I’m wondering whether governments are really going to be that willing to give IMF that much power, considering that it wasn’t getting much love from any quarters until the euro crisis started (and the Greeks aren’t loving IMF much right now).

    Having said all that, one really does wish that American politicians would get their acts together.

    • I agree with you on the rapid decline of the Euro, albeit unexpected. Even Jean-Claude Trichet, the ECB President has voiced his concerns around the unsuitability of the Euro as a global reserve currency. The fact that assets of 5 member nations held by the ECB were discounted by the market this year, all but confirms this. The post is a meek endorsement of the greenback. The lack of a clear substitute (notice I’ve ignored the RMB) suggests the end is anything but nigh for the USD.

  4. It was an easy read. Even though I am not an economist, I have always been a big fan of Joseph Stiglitz. The days of US being the World Power are numbered. Nice one!

  5. Thanks for providing me with some explanations to a question I’ve long asked: Why is the Naira ‘tied’ (or indexed) to the U.S. Dollar? It is the global reserve currency.
    I have no fears for a world ahead not dominated by a single currency; I am more focused on the opportunities awaiting exploration.

  6. Well written and interesting post. I however noticed that you did not offer a suggestion on alternative currency for international transactions and also as a basis for comparison. If I get an offer in Euros and in Dirhams, I usually convert to Dollars to compare competitiveness. I think the Dollar will continue to serve this purpose even if SDRs are used for managing reserves.

    • I don’t think an alternative currency can replace the USD, it will not replace any of the risks affecting the dollar today. None springs to mind, so in this regard you are correct that the dollar won’t be replaced any time soon. The post just highlights that a discussion that was unthinkable in the 90’s has started. Whether it will lead to a replacement of the USD as the global reserve currency is certainly not clear at the moment.

  7. Very very insightful piece, Akin. Great job. The ‘Triffin Dilemma’ is spot on. The Keynesian SDR concept however gives some concern. First, how many countries will consent to an IMF led reserve bank? Certainly not the likes of Greece or ‘victims’ of previous stringent policies like the ‘Structural Adjustment Program’. The concept of valuing the SDR exchange rate via an average of all currencies held is cause for concern..wondering about the impact of this on global trade – balancing act or otherwise? Thanks for sharing FINALLY 🙂

  8. *Coughs*

    No, I’m not about to post any ‘financial’ comment… That’s not my specialty.

    Errrrmmm, while the dollar is being ‘demystified’ on one side, can you do a post on guidelines on how to ‘make a dollar’ …

    My body need money in foreign currency abeg (Not Zimbabwean dollars please).


  9. Nice one and four comments (based on my limited knowledge):
    – Global Currencies need to provide liquidity, general economic stability and reduced risk
    – that said, RMB has limited liquidity, Euro while a contender on the liquidity front faces general economic instability
    – While the SDR needs to be further clarified.
    – So as you said, mixed winds blow from the east, we await a clearer picture.
    once again Nice effort…

  10. Gbireeeeeeeeeeee!!!! Fire on!!

    See my people coming here to show their skills… Correct!

    I can’t go hungry having you guys as my buddies be that…

    Oya oya, time to translate all this English into ‘Green Account balance’


  11. funny I had a convo on SDR, USD n America remaining d world power earlier today, very explanatory piece u ve here but I dont see the world changing global reserve currency anytime soon, I find that d economists don’t know when they are talking politics.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s